Day 281 of the Daily · Innovation

Pretotyping

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. There’s a cheaper question than can we build this, and hardly anyone asks it first.

The question

For the thing you’re planning to build this quarter, what’s the smallest and most embarrassing version you could put in front of a stranger this week — a sign, a page, a form, you doing the work by hand — and what would you need to watch them do before you’d believe the demand is real? If you can’t picture that version, it is usually because you’d rather not find out yet.

The idea

Day 29 handed you the minimum viable product: the smallest thing you can build to test the riskiest assumption. Alberto Savoia’s argument is that a cheaper question sits underneath it, and that it can usually be asked before anything is built. Savoia was an engineering director at Google in its early years and later its innovation agitator; he set the case out in a free ebook, Pretotype It, in 2011, and expanded it into The Right It in 2019. It starts on an unwelcome observation: most new products fail in the market, and they fail after being built competently, on time, by capable people. The failure isn’t execution. It’s that the thing was never wanted. So Savoia splits the question in two. A prototype answers can we build it. A pretotype answers would anyone use it, and it is meant to be answered first, in days, usually with nothing built at all. Savoia counts a stripped-down MVP as a pretotype too, though it takes more work than the faked kinds because it has to function. Jeff Hawkins famously carried a block of wood, cut to the size of the handheld organiser he was thinking of building, in his shirt pocket for months, tapping at it with a chopstick to learn whether he’d reach for such a thing often enough to justify the build. Most people test an idea by describing it instead, which is why they get such encouraging answers: being encouraging is free.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Pretotyping is Day 281 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 290 · Innovation

Co-Innovation Risk

Take the thing you plan to launch next year and count everyone outside your business who has to do something new before a customer gets any value from it at all — the supplier who has to make a part that doesn’t exist yet, the installer who has to learn a procedure, the regulator who has to write a rule, the retailer who has to stock something nobody has asked for — and then ask what each of them would privately put their own odds at. You’ve costed your own risk carefully. The rest of the chain sits in the plan as one word: partners.

See the framework →
Day 299 · Innovation

Discovery-Driven Planning

For the venture you’re most excited about, do you know the profit it has to earn before it’s worth doing at all — and, separately, the price, the volume and the unit cost the world would have to hand you for that profit to exist? Most people can produce the first on request. The second is the one that settles it, and almost nobody has written it down.

See the framework →
Day 304 · Innovation

The Innovation Tournament

Count the genuinely separate attempts you have running at the problem you most need solved — separate in approach, not merely in name, so that one of them failing would tell you nothing about the others — and if the honest count comes to one, what exactly is meant to happen on the day that one turns out to be wrong? Most plans have no answer, because the plan was that it wouldn’t be.

See the framework →
Day 313 · Innovation

Stage-Gate

Of everything your business has started in the last two years, how many were formally stopped at a meeting where stopping was one of the options on the table — and how many just thinned out until nobody could say when they’d ended? The difference between those two numbers is money you no longer have.

See the framework →