Day 299 of the Daily · Innovation

Discovery-Driven Planning

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. Almost every figure in a new venture’s plan is an assumption. The format hides that.

The question

For the venture you’re most excited about, do you know the profit it has to earn before it’s worth doing at all — and, separately, the price, the volume and the unit cost the world would have to hand you for that profit to exist? Most people can produce the first on request. The second is the one that settles it, and almost nobody has written it down.

The idea

Rita Gunther McGrath of Columbia Business School and Ian MacMillan of Wharton published Discovery-Driven Planning in the Harvard Business Review in 1995, and their complaint was about a specific document: the new-venture plan built the way an established business builds a budget. Conventional planning extrapolates from a base of things already known. A new venture has almost no base, and the format quietly converts what it does have — assumptions — into figures nobody argues with again. Their fix reverses the arithmetic. You start from the profit the venture has to deliver to be worth doing, work out the revenue that would have to exist for that profit to be plausible, and subtract one from the other. What’s left is what they call the allowable cost: not what you’d like the thing to cost, but what it is permitted to cost. Then you carry on backwards through the operations that would have to run, and every quantity the arithmetic has fixed goes on a list to be tested in order — which is Assumption Mapping’s job again, done with numbers instead of cards. The worked case in the article follows Kao Corporation, the Japanese soap and chemicals company, weighing whether to enter the floppy-disk business it had been supplying for years. A plan graded by how close the outcome came to the forecast teaches you nothing. This one is graded by how cheaply its assumptions turned into knowledge.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Discovery-Driven Planning is Day 299 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 304 · Innovation

The Innovation Tournament

Count the genuinely separate attempts you have running at the problem you most need solved — separate in approach, not merely in name, so that one of them failing would tell you nothing about the others — and if the honest count comes to one, what exactly is meant to happen on the day that one turns out to be wrong? Most plans have no answer, because the plan was that it wouldn’t be.

See the framework →
Day 313 · Innovation

Stage-Gate

Of everything your business has started in the last two years, how many were formally stopped at a meeting where stopping was one of the options on the table — and how many just thinned out until nobody could say when they’d ended? The difference between those two numbers is money you no longer have.

See the framework →
Day 320 · Innovation

Kill Criteria

Name the bet you’re currently running with real money in it, and then say what would have to be true — and by what date — for you to walk away from it: is there an answer, or have you just discovered that the criterion you’re actually using is that the bet ends when the money does?

See the framework →
Day 329 · Innovation

The Ambition Matrix

Take last year’s spend on anything you’d call new, work out what share went to work you could already price — improvements to what you sell, for the people already buying it — and if that share is over ninety per cent, what exactly is meant to be earning your money in five years, given that nobody in the building has yet been asked to fund it?

See the framework →