Day 313 of the Daily · Innovation

Stage-Gate

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. Every project your business has ever started is still technically alive. That’s the problem.

The question

Of everything your business has started in the last two years, how many were formally stopped at a meeting where stopping was one of the options on the table — and how many just thinned out until nobody could say when they’d ended? The difference between those two numbers is money you no longer have.

The idea

Robert G. Cooper, a professor at McMaster University’s DeGroote School of Business in Ontario, spent years studying hundreds of new-product launches to find what separated the successes from the failures, first put the result into print as Stage-Gate in 1988, and set it out for managers in Business Horizons in 1990. The structure is deliberately dull. Work is divided into stages — scoping, business case, development, testing, launch — and between every pair sits a gate: a meeting with named attendees, a fixed set of deliverables due beforehand, criteria agreed in advance, and an output that is more than a verdict. Cooper split those criteria in two. Must-meet criteria form a checklist that removes misfits quickly. Should-meet criteria are scored, so projects can be ranked against one another instead of each being judged alone. And a gate has four available verdicts rather than two: go, kill, hold, recycle. The trap is the gate that has only ever said go. Cooper has returned to that failure for decades since — his own name for the remedy is gates with teeth — because a gate where nothing has ever been stopped isn’t a decision any more. It’s a milestone with catering, and the pipeline behind it fills up with work everybody privately knows is finished.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Stage-Gate is Day 313 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 320 · Innovation

Kill Criteria

Name the bet you’re currently running with real money in it, and then say what would have to be true — and by what date — for you to walk away from it: is there an answer, or have you just discovered that the criterion you’re actually using is that the bet ends when the money does?

See the framework →
Day 329 · Innovation

The Ambition Matrix

Take last year’s spend on anything you’d call new, work out what share went to work you could already price — improvements to what you sell, for the people already buying it — and if that share is over ninety per cent, what exactly is meant to be earning your money in five years, given that nobody in the building has yet been asked to fund it?

See the framework →
Day 337 · Innovation

The Ambidextrous Organisation

The new thing you’re building inside the existing business — is it measured on the same numbers, staffed from the same pool and reviewed in the same meeting as the part that already works, and if it is, who exactly is going to protect it the first quarter the core misses its forecast?

See the framework →
Day 346 · Innovation

Profiting from Innovation

Between the thing you’ve built and the money a customer pays for it sits a list of other people’s property: a channel, a factory, a sales force, an approval, a brand a cautious buyer already trusts. Can you name every item on that list for your own business, and write an owner beside each one? The item you can’t name is where the profit goes, and it goes there whether or not the idea was yours.

See the framework →