Day 346 of the Daily · Innovation

Profiting from Innovation

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Somebody’s going to get paid for your idea. Nothing says it has to be you.

The question

Between the thing you’ve built and the money a customer pays for it sits a list of other people’s property: a channel, a factory, a sales force, an approval, a brand a cautious buyer already trusts. Can you name every item on that list for your own business, and write an owner beside each one? The item you can’t name is where the profit goes, and it goes there whether or not the idea was yours.

The idea

David Teece, an economist at the University of California, Berkeley, published a paper in Research Policy in 1986 asking why the pioneer so often fails to get paid. EMI built the first CT scanner and Godfrey Hounsfield shared a Nobel Prize for it in 1979; within a few years EMI had left the business, and the profits went to competitors — General Electric among them — who had invented none of it. Teece’s answer turns on two conditions, and only one of them is about the idea. The first is how well the innovation resists copying, which you’ve already tested twice on other mornings. The second is the one nothing so far has covered: complementary assets — manufacturing, distribution, the sales force, the service network, the regulatory file, the brand that makes a cautious buyer say yes. The unglamorous machinery an idea has to pass through before it becomes revenue. Where copying is easy, the profit flows to whoever holds that machinery, and that’s usually the incumbent you were hoping to go around. Most founders spend the entire protection budget on the part they’re proudest of and never price the road. Royal Crown launched the first diet cola; Coca-Cola and Pepsi had the marketing and the brands, and they’re the names you know.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Profiting from Innovation is Day 346 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 355 · Innovation

Designing for Adoption

Think of the last thing you launched that deserved to do better than it did — can you say which of its adoption properties you got wrong: the advantage it offered over the workaround people already had, how well it fitted the way they already work, how much they had to swallow before the first payoff, how cheaply they could try it, and whether anyone could see them using it? Most teams can’t, which is why the post-mortem always lands on the marketing.

See the framework →
Day 364 · Innovation

The Innovation Operating Review

How many of the innovation bets you’re running right now could you describe from memory — what each has cost in money and in your own attention, what it has proved rather than merely produced, and the written condition that would end it? The ones you can’t describe aren’t dormant. They’re quietly holding the capacity you keep telling yourself you’d need before you could try something new.

See the framework →
Day 175 · Innovation

New Combinations

Think of the idea you parked because it needed something you don’t have — the technology, the licence, the capability, the partner: could you write out now, line by line, which parts of it are genuinely missing and which are already sitting somewhere in your business, your suppliers’ hands or your customers’? The cost of never writing that list is that a shortage you never verified keeps deciding what you attempt.

See the framework →
Day 184 · Innovation

Exploration and Exploitation

Add up where your best people went last quarter: how many hours went into making something you already sell work slightly better, and how many went into finding out whether something you don’t sell yet could work at all — and if the second number is close to zero, notice that nobody chose it. Every individual decision that produced it was correct, which is exactly what makes it so hard to reverse.

See the framework →