Day 184 of the Daily · Innovation

Exploration and Exploitation

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Nobody in your business decided to stop looking for the next thing. It simply stopped being worth anyone’s while.

The question

Add up where your best people went last quarter: how many hours went into making something you already sell work slightly better, and how many went into finding out whether something you don’t sell yet could work at all — and if the second number is close to zero, notice that nobody chose it. Every individual decision that produced it was correct, which is exactly what makes it so hard to reverse.

The idea

James March spent the long back half of his career at Stanford, holding chairs in management, political science, sociology and education at the same time, and in 1991 he published a paper in Organization Science called Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning. Its argument is arithmetic rather than moral. Exploitation — refining, selecting, executing, making the existing thing better — has returns March described as positive, proximate and predictable. Exploration — search, variation, experiment, discovery — has returns he described as uncertain, distant and often negative. If that sounds like Christensen’s innovator’s dilemma, it isn’t the same claim. Christensen explains why an incumbent rationally declines one particular low-margin market, and he needs a disruptor for the story to bite. March’s result is more general and a good deal more uncomfortable: the same arithmetic strips search out of any organisation’s portfolio with no disruptor anywhere in sight, and because organisations learn from their own experience, they get better at whichever one they do more of — which raises exploitation’s returns again and makes the next comparison more lopsided still. Nobody in the building is being short-sighted. They’re each correctly preferring a certain return to an uncertain one, and the sum of correct preferences is a business that has quietly stopped looking.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Exploration and Exploitation is Day 184 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 193 · Innovation

The Ten Types

Take the last three things your business genuinely changed — not the tweaks, the changes — and place each one: was it the product itself, or was it how you charge, who you build it with, how the work gets done, how it reaches the buyer, what it feels like to be your customer? If you already know all three land in the same place, you don’t have an innovation problem — you have a range problem, and that one’s cheaper to fix.

See the framework →
Day 202 · Innovation

The Seven Sources

When something went unexpectedly well for you this year — the region that beat plan with no help from you, the quiet product line that carried the quarter, the tender you nearly didn’t bid for and won — did anything in the business actually change, or did you find a reason it didn’t count and go back to the plan? Almost everyone finds the reason. That reason is the cost: you were handed the information free and then threw it away.

See the framework →
Day 210 · Innovation

Lead Users

The last time you went looking for what to build next, whose desk did you go to — the reasonable, representative, available customer who’d give you a considered opinion about the thing you’d already half decided on? I’ll answer for you: that’s who nearly everyone asks, because they’re easy to reach and they’re polite. The people who could have told you something you didn’t know had stopped waiting and built it themselves.

See the framework →
Day 219 · Innovation

Open Innovation

Add up what your business has paid to develop and then decided not to ship — and then ask how many of those things you’ve ever offered to anybody, at any price, on any terms?

See the framework →