Day 290 of the Daily · Innovation

Co-Innovation Risk

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Your part of this will work. It’s almost never your part that decides.

The question

Take the thing you plan to launch next year and count everyone outside your business who has to do something new before a customer gets any value from it at all — the supplier who has to make a part that doesn’t exist yet, the installer who has to learn a procedure, the regulator who has to write a rule, the retailer who has to stock something nobody has asked for — and then ask what each of them would privately put their own odds at. You’ve costed your own risk carefully. The rest of the chain sits in the plan as one word: partners.

The idea

Ron Adner was teaching strategy at INSEAD when the Harvard Business Review published Match Your Innovation Strategy to Your Innovation Ecosystem in April 2006, where he named three risks: initiative, interdependence and integration. He rebuilt the argument as The Wide Lens in 2012, by then at Dartmouth’s Tuck School, and renamed them execution, co-innovation and adoption chain — the names they travel under now. Execution risk is what your project plan is made of: can we build it, on time, to spec. Co-innovation risk is how far your success waits on other innovations succeeding first, elsewhere, on somebody else’s schedule. Adoption chain risk is how many intermediaries must take the thing up before an end customer sees any value. Michelin’s run-flat tyre carried both of the last two. The tyre talked to the car’s electronics, so it fitted only vehicles designed to accommodate it, and Michelin waited on a willing manufacturer’s design window — three to four years before volume production. Behind the carmakers sat dealers who had to support the system and repair shops that had to buy service equipment. Nine years after its introduction, the article reports, it was standard on a handful of car models. High-definition television had the same shape, over decades. Then do the arithmetic. Give yourself a generous nine in ten, and four partners nine in ten each. Nine-tenths to the fifth is fifty-nine per cent. Nobody in the room ever multiplies.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Co-Innovation Risk is Day 290 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 299 · Innovation

Discovery-Driven Planning

For the venture you’re most excited about, do you know the profit it has to earn before it’s worth doing at all — and, separately, the price, the volume and the unit cost the world would have to hand you for that profit to exist? Most people can produce the first on request. The second is the one that settles it, and almost nobody has written it down.

See the framework →
Day 304 · Innovation

The Innovation Tournament

Count the genuinely separate attempts you have running at the problem you most need solved — separate in approach, not merely in name, so that one of them failing would tell you nothing about the others — and if the honest count comes to one, what exactly is meant to happen on the day that one turns out to be wrong? Most plans have no answer, because the plan was that it wouldn’t be.

See the framework →
Day 313 · Innovation

Stage-Gate

Of everything your business has started in the last two years, how many were formally stopped at a meeting where stopping was one of the options on the table — and how many just thinned out until nobody could say when they’d ended? The difference between those two numbers is money you no longer have.

See the framework →
Day 320 · Innovation

Kill Criteria

Name the bet you’re currently running with real money in it, and then say what would have to be true — and by what date — for you to walk away from it: is there an answer, or have you just discovered that the criterion you’re actually using is that the bet ends when the money does?

See the framework →