Day 075 of the Daily · Strategy

The Payoff Matrix

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Your next move has a reply. Most plans leave it out.

The question

The next time you cut a price, match an offer, or move into a rival’s territory, they get to move too — so for the competitive decision on your desk this week, can you write down their most likely reply and what the board looks like after it, and if you can’t, why haven’t you scored the game before playing your half of it?

The idea

Game theory entered economics in 1944, when the mathematician John von Neumann and the economist Oskar Morgenstern published Theory of Games and Economic Behavior — a book built on one observation: in competitive situations, the outcome of your decision depends on decisions other people are making at the same time, in their own interest. The payoff matrix is the working tool that fell out of it: a small grid with your options on one axis, a rival’s options on the other, and in every cell what each side wins or loses. John Nash later supplied the thing the grid exists to find — the equilibrium, the cell where neither side can do better by changing their move alone. Most people plan competitive moves against a frozen world: the price cut is modelled, the spreadsheet approves it, and nowhere does the model contain the competitor’s Tuesday-morning meeting about how to respond. That is the trap — strategy against opponents who don’t move. The matrix forces the reply into the plan before you commit to it.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Payoff Matrix is Day 75 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Strategy

The next four in the course.

All 30 Strategy frameworks
Day 077 · Strategy

The Red Queen Effect

List what your business got measurably better at over the past year — faster delivery, sharper product, better service — then mark how many of those gains your closest competitor has already matched or will match within a year; if the honest answer is most of them, what did all that running actually buy you, and why haven’t you separated the effort that keeps you in the race from the effort that gets you ahead of it?

See the framework →
Day 079 · Strategy

Strategic Trade-offs

Read your current plan and find one thing it explicitly refuses — a customer you’ll turn away, a feature you won’t build, revenue you’ll decline. If you can’t find one, you’re holding a to-do list wearing a strategy’s clothes — so why haven’t you sat down and decided what your position costs?

See the framework →
Day 081 · Strategy

The Adjacency Ladder

For the expansion you’re weighing right now — the new segment, product, market or channel — can you count exactly how many things about it are new to you: the customer, the product, the channel, the capability; and if the count is more than one, why haven’t you gone looking for the one-step move you’re skipping over?

See the framework →
Day 083 · Strategy

Make or Buy

Walk the capabilities your business runs on — the product, the pipeline, the delivery, the books, the brand — and ask of each one: did someone decide it should be in-house or bought in, or did the boundary just accrete; and if the thing customers actually choose you for is currently rented from a vendor who also serves your competitors, why is it still on someone else’s payroll?

See the framework →