Day 083 of the Daily · Strategy

Make or Buy

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Every capability in your business is a decision — including the ones you never noticed making.

The question

Walk the capabilities your business runs on — the product, the pipeline, the delivery, the books, the brand — and ask of each one: did someone decide it should be in-house or bought in, or did the boundary just accrete; and if the thing customers actually choose you for is currently rented from a vendor who also serves your competitors, why is it still on someone else’s payroll?

The idea

In 1937 a young economist named Ronald Coase asked a question so basic that nobody had thought to answer it: if markets are so good at allocating resources, why do firms exist at all — why isn’t everything bought in? His answer, in The Nature of the Firm, won him a Nobel Prize and founded a field: using the market has costs the invoice never shows — finding the supplier, negotiating the deal, coordinating the work, enforcing the quality. Firms exist to bring activities inside when those transaction costs exceed the cost of managing them yourself. Oliver Williamson spent a career sharpening the same idea and collected his own Nobel for it in 2009. Then C.K. Prahalad and Gary Hamel added the strategic half in their 1990 Harvard Business Review article on core competence: some capabilities are not costs to be minimised at all — they are the reason customers choose you, and they compound. The trap is deciding make-or-buy as a procurement question. Most people compare the vendor’s quote with an internal salary and take the smaller number — which is how companies end up outsourcing the capability that made them distinctive because it looked expensive, while lovingly hand-building commodity work a vendor does better for half the price.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Make or Buy is Day 83 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Strategy

The next four in the course.

All 30 Strategy frameworks
Day 085 · Strategy

The Three Horizons

Sort everything your business will spend real effort on this quarter into three piles — earning today, building the next earner, seeding the one after — and look at the second and third piles: if the honest answer is that the core has quietly eaten them, what exactly will you be selling in three years, and why haven’t you booked the hour that starts the rebalance?

See the framework →
Day 087 · Strategy

The OODA Loop

When the ground last shifted under you — the competitor’s launch, the channel that stopped converting, the customer who quietly changed what they wanted — how long passed between the moment the evidence existed and the moment you acted on it; and if the honest answer is that you saw it in week one and moved in month three, why are you blaming the pace of the market instead of the length of your loop?

See the framework →
Day 089 · Strategy

The Crux

If you had to name the single hardest obstacle standing between your business and its next stage — one problem, stated in a sentence, not a list of ambitions — could you do it right now; and if you can’t, why does a strategy document already exist that promises to get you past it?

See the framework →
Day 091 · Strategy

Counter-positioning

Somewhere in your market an incumbent is funded by a line its customers resent — the late fee, the commission, the lock-in, the markup — and you can probably name it in one breath; so why haven’t you designed the offer that deletes that line, and written the memo that tells you whether they could afford to follow?

See the framework →