Day 068 of the Daily · Decision Making

Satisficing vs Maximising

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. You spent three weeks choosing something that deserved an afternoon.

The question

Think of the decision you are still shopping — three quotes in, four candidates seen, none of them chosen. Is the next option going to tell you something the last three did not, or are you waiting for one of them to feel best enough to let you stop, and paying for that wait in weeks you will not get back?

The idea

Herbert Simon won the 1978 Nobel Prize in Economics for his pioneering research into how decisions are made inside economic organisations. Real decision-makers do not optimise, he argued, because they cannot: in A Behavioral Model of Rational Choice (1955) he set out bounded rationality — limited information, limited time, limited attention — and the following year he coined satisficing, a blend of satisfy and suffice. You set a standard for what would be good enough, search until something meets it, and stop. Maximising searches the whole field for the best. Simon’s claim was not that satisficing is a lesser method for lazier people; under real constraints it is the rational one. Half a century later, Sheena Iyengar, Rachael Wells and Barry Schwartz followed graduating students through a job hunt (Psychological Science, 2006) and found the maximisers among them landed jobs paying around twenty per cent more, and felt worse for it: more regret and more anxiety through the search, and less satisfaction with the jobs they took. A better outcome, bought at a price nobody had priced.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Satisficing vs Maximising is Day 68 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Decision Making

The next four in the course.

All 28 Decision Making frameworks
Day 070 · Decision Making

The Ladder of Inference

Think of the colleague you have quietly filed as unreliable, or the market you have decided is not worth entering: can you separate the few things you actually observed from the story you assembled on top of them? If the whole conviction turns out to rest on two incidents and a tone of voice, you already know why you have never gone back to check — everything that has happened since has agreed with you.

See the framework →
Day 072 · Decision Making

Red Teaming

Think of the largest decision your business has made this year, and name the person whose job it was to argue against it. If the honest answer is nobody, or the most junior person in the room for five uncomfortable minutes at the end, then the strongest case against that decision has still not been made — and you will meet it later, from the market, at full price.

See the framework →
Day 074 · Decision Making

Anchoring in Decisions

Think of the last significant number you agreed to — a price, a salary, a budget, a delivery date — and say where it originally came from. If the honest answer is that it came from the other side of the table, then what you have been calling negotiation was arithmetic performed on somebody else’s figure.

See the framework →
Day 076 · Decision Making

Decision Rights

Think of the decision that keeps reappearing on the agenda under a new owner — yours this month, a colleague’s last month, nobody’s the month before that: name the one person entitled to settle it without checking with anyone. If no name comes to you, the reason is almost never that the decision is hard; it is that nobody has ever written down who decides, who advises and who is simply going to be told.

See the framework →