Day 072 of the Daily · Decision Making

Red Teaming

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Every decision you make has an opposing case, and nobody in the room is paid to make it.

The question

Think of the largest decision your business has made this year, and name the person whose job it was to argue against it. If the honest answer is nobody, or the most junior person in the room for five uncomfortable minutes at the end, then the strongest case against that decision has still not been made — and you will meet it later, from the market, at full price.

The idea

Two rooms get the same problem and the same lone objector. In one the objector genuinely disagrees; in the other they have been told to play devil’s advocate. The rooms do not think alike. Charlan Nemeth, a psychologist at the University of California, Berkeley, ran that comparison with Joanie Connell, John Rogers and Keith Brown and published it in 2001: authentic dissent drew more original thinking from the group than the assigned role did, and the devil’s advocate mostly led people to shore up the view they started with. The rest of her work, gathered in In Defense of Troublemakers (2018), is the case for the real thing — a group that hears a genuine minority view searches wider, generates more options and reaches better judgements, even when the dissenter turns out to be wrong. Red teaming is the organisational answer to that gap: not a role performed for ten minutes at the end of a meeting, but a real brief, given to named people, resourced and rewarded, to construct the strongest available case that you are about to make a mistake. Most people test their decisions by describing them to allies.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Red Teaming is Day 72 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Decision Making

The next four in the course.

All 28 Decision Making frameworks
Day 074 · Decision Making

Anchoring in Decisions

Think of the last significant number you agreed to — a price, a salary, a budget, a delivery date — and say where it originally came from. If the honest answer is that it came from the other side of the table, then what you have been calling negotiation was arithmetic performed on somebody else’s figure.

See the framework →
Day 076 · Decision Making

Decision Rights

Think of the decision that keeps reappearing on the agenda under a new owner — yours this month, a colleague’s last month, nobody’s the month before that: name the one person entitled to settle it without checking with anyone. If no name comes to you, the reason is almost never that the decision is hard; it is that nobody has ever written down who decides, who advises and who is simply going to be told.

See the framework →
Day 078 · Decision Making

The Planning Fallacy

How long did the last three things you promised in a fortnight actually take? If you cannot answer that this morning without guessing, today’s frame is already settled — you are about to produce another number by the method that produced those three, and the one record that would correct it has never been written down.

See the framework →
Day 080 · Decision Making

Optionality

Which commitment in front of you this week would genuinely be expensive to undo, and what would it cost — a deposit, a break clause, a pilot, three more weeks — to buy yourself the right to decide it once you know more? If you have never put a number on that, the reason is usually one of two: the option is genuinely unaffordable, or deciding now feels braver than admitting what you still don’t know.

See the framework →