Day 062 of the Daily · Decision Making

Decision Journals

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. The call you are proudest of may simply have got lucky.

The question

Take the decision you rate most highly from the past year and ask honestly whether you rate it because the reasoning was sound or because the number came in. If the two have fused, your memory is not the problem — you kept the result and threw the reasoning away, and only one of those was ever yours.

The idea

In 1988 the psychologists Jonathan Baron and John Hershey published ‘Outcome bias in decision evaluation’ in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Readers were given a medical decision to assess — the same odds, the same information available at the time — and then told how it turned out. Those who learned the patient had died rated the decision itself as worse than those told the patient had recovered. Nothing about the reasoning had changed; only the result had. Michael Mauboussin, the investment strategist and adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, prescribed the antidote in Think Twice (2009): a decision journal, written before the outcome is known, recording what you chose, what you expected, and why. Judging backwards from results — Annie Duke’s Thinking in Bets (2018) calls it resulting — teaches you almost nothing, because in any business with luck in it, sound decisions sometimes lose and careless ones sometimes pay. Most people keep a record of what happened. Almost nobody keeps a record of what they thought would happen.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Decision Journals is Day 62 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Decision Making

The next four in the course.

All 28 Decision Making frameworks
Day 064 · Decision Making

Reversible vs Irreversible

Think of the decision that has sat unmade on your desk for a fortnight: if you got it wrong, what exactly would the walk back cost you in money, in weeks and in trust? If the honest answer is “not much”, the fortnight has bought you nothing — you have been running a board-level process on a door that swings both ways.

See the framework →
Day 066 · Decision Making

Availability Bias

Think about the risk your team has spent the most energy guarding against this quarter: is it genuinely the most likely thing to damage you, or simply the most recent thing to damage somebody you know? If the answer will not come without going and counting, you already have it — the quarter has been spent defending against a story you can retell rather than a number you have checked.

See the framework →
Day 068 · Decision Making

Satisficing vs Maximising

Think of the decision you are still shopping — three quotes in, four candidates seen, none of them chosen. Is the next option going to tell you something the last three did not, or are you waiting for one of them to feel best enough to let you stop, and paying for that wait in weeks you will not get back?

See the framework →
Day 070 · Decision Making

The Ladder of Inference

Think of the colleague you have quietly filed as unreliable, or the market you have decided is not worth entering: can you separate the few things you actually observed from the story you assembled on top of them? If the whole conviction turns out to rest on two incidents and a tone of voice, you already know why you have never gone back to check — everything that has happened since has agreed with you.

See the framework →