Day 054 of the Daily · Decision Making

Base Rates

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Before you ask how your plan will go, find out how it usually goes.

The question

For the decision in front of you this week — the hire, the build, the raise, the launch — do you know what happened to the last hundred people who stood roughly where you stand? If you have never looked, the reason is rarely that the number doesn’t exist; it is that you can already guess what it says.

The idea

Fewer than one in ten came in on both budget and schedule. That is the record of more than sixteen thousand projects — bridges, dams, IT systems, Olympic Games — collected over decades by Bent Flyvbjerg, the first BT Professor and Chair of Major Programme Management at Oxford’s Saïd Business School, and reported in How Big Things Get Done (2023), written with Dan Gardner. Their planners, Flyvbjerg finds, tend to look closely at their own circumstances and conclude they are the exception. Flyvbjerg’s remedy is reference class forecasting, built on Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky’s work and on the distinction Kahneman later drew with Dan Lovallo between the inside view — the details of your case, your team, your plan — and the outside view, which asks a duller question: what happened to the last hundred people who attempted roughly this? The outside view’s answer is the base rate. What makes this hard is that the inside view feels like knowledge. It is specific, it is yours, and it is almost always more optimistic than the record.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Base Rates is Day 54 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Decision Making

The next four in the course.

All 28 Decision Making frameworks
Day 056 · Decision Making

Expected Value

Think of the decision you are closest to committing to: could you state the four or five ways it could actually end, with a number against each and a payoff written in the same unit? Most people cannot — the whole thing has been running on one vivid outcome, and the branches that would compete with it have never been put anywhere you could argue with them.

See the framework →
Day 058 · Decision Making

Confirmation Bias

Take the belief your business is currently most committed to — the customer you are sure you understand, the channel you are sure is working, the hire you are sure was right — and name the specific thing you could observe that would tell you it is wrong; and if you cannot name it, or you can name it but have never gone looking, why do you keep calling the pile of evidence on your desk research when you assembled every piece of it yourself?

See the framework →
Day 060 · Decision Making

The Sunk Cost Trap

Name the project, contract or hire you are still carrying largely because of what it has already cost you — the one you would not begin today at any price — and if the name surfaced before you finished reading the sentence, why is it still funded in next week’s plan?

See the framework →
Day 062 · Decision Making

Decision Journals

Take the decision you rate most highly from the past year and ask honestly whether you rate it because the reasoning was sound or because the number came in. If the two have fused, your memory is not the problem — you kept the result and threw the reasoning away, and only one of those was ever yours.

See the framework →