Day 308 of the Daily · Talent Management

Adding Up, Not Sizing Up

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. The room agrees she interviewed best. That isn’t the same as scoring best.

The question

Think about the last person you hired: when the decision actually got made, was there a total on the page — a number per candidate, produced by a rule fixed weeks earlier — and could every person in the room see it, or was there a sheet in front of one of you and a conversation in front of the rest? If no total existed, you’ll never know whether your process works, because you never wrote down what it predicted.

The idea

Paul Meehl was a clinical psychologist at the University of Minnesota, and in 1954 he published a short book that made him permanently unpopular with much of his own profession. Clinical versus Statistical Prediction asked a narrow question: given the same evidence, does the expert reading it as a whole beat a simple formula that adds the pieces up? He gathered the head-to-head comparisons that existed and found the formula matched or beat the expert almost every time. Forty-two years later, William Grove and Meehl revisited it across 136 studies, spanning everything from medical diagnosis to who reoffends to who succeeds in a job. Sixty-four favoured the mechanical rule. Sixty-four came out roughly level. Eight favoured the human. Notice what isn’t being argued here: nobody’s telling you to drop the interview. The evidence can be as rich and as human as you like. What loses is the last step — the moment you sweep the scores off the table and size the candidate up. The trap is that this step feels like the most skilled thing you do all week. It’s the only part of your process that’s ever been tested against arithmetic and lost.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Adding Up, Not Sizing Up is Day 308 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Talent Management

The next four in the course.

All 19 Talent Management frameworks
Day 319 · Talent Management

The First Week

Cast your mind back to your own first morning at the last place you joined: how many of those hours went on being told what the company believed, and how many went on anybody finding out what you were actually good at? You already know the ratio. So does everyone else — and it’s the same ratio you’re running on your own new starters right now.

See the framework →
Day 328 · Talent Management

Job Embeddedness

Take the one person on your team whose resignation would genuinely hurt: can you name three relationships they’d lose by leaving, one way this job fits a life they’ve built outside it, and three things they’d have to give up that have nothing to do with salary? Most founders can recite what they pay that person to the dollar. Almost none can list what holds them.

See the framework →
Day 339 · Talent Management

The Pay Comparison

If every salary in your business appeared on a shared spreadsheet tonight, which three people would find themselves sitting below someone they consider their equal — and could you finish the sentence that begins ‘you are paid less than them because’ for each one, out loud, without flinching? The gaps where that sentence runs out are the ones already costing you.

See the framework →
Day 348 · Talent Management

The Shock, Not the Slide

Take the last good person who resigned on you and work backwards through the six weeks before the conversation: what actually happened to them in that window — a promotion that went somewhere else, a restructure, a client who humiliated them in front of the team, a friend’s offer, a funeral, a baby? Something did. You almost certainly heard about it at the time and filed it as a bad week.

See the framework →