Day 339 of the Daily · Talent Management

The Pay Comparison

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. The number in that offer letter isn’t private. It’s undisclosed, and there’s a difference.

The question

If every salary in your business appeared on a shared spreadsheet tonight, which three people would find themselves sitting below someone they consider their equal — and could you finish the sentence that begins ‘you are paid less than them because’ for each one, out loud, without flinching? The gaps where that sentence runs out are the ones already costing you.

The idea

J. Stacy Adams was a behavioural psychologist inside General Electric’s research unit when he published a paper in the Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology in 1963 called Towards an Understanding of Inequity. His claim was that people don’t evaluate what they get. They evaluate a ratio — what they put in against what they receive — and then set that ratio beside somebody else’s. The comparison person is chosen, not assigned, and the tension that follows has almost nothing to do with the absolute figure. Nearly fifty years later four economists — David Card, who’d go on to share the Nobel in economics in 2021, with Alexandre Mas, Enrico Moretti and Emmanuel Saez — got to run it as a real experiment. A newspaper had put University of California salaries on a searchable website. The researchers told a randomly chosen subset of employees the site existed, then surveyed everybody about satisfaction and about whether they were looking elsewhere. What came back was lopsided. Learning the site existed made no significant difference to the people who then found themselves above the median for their own pay unit and occupation — no lift in satisfaction, no change in their plans to look elsewhere. It did a great deal to the people who found themselves below it, who reported lower satisfaction with their pay and their jobs and a markedly higher chance of looking elsewhere. The response ran one way only, and that asymmetry is what tells you the comparison rather than the salary was doing the damage. The trap is treating pay secrecy as a pay structure. Secrecy only postpones the comparison; the structure is what has to survive it, and most founders haven’t written theirs down.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Pay Comparison is Day 339 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Talent Management

The next four in the course.

All 19 Talent Management frameworks
Day 348 · Talent Management

The Shock, Not the Slide

Take the last good person who resigned on you and work backwards through the six weeks before the conversation: what actually happened to them in that window — a promotion that went somewhere else, a restructure, a client who humiliated them in front of the team, a friend’s offer, a funeral, a baby? Something did. You almost certainly heard about it at the time and filed it as a bad week.

See the framework →
Day 357 · Talent Management

The Talent Operating Review

The first morning of this elective asked how many of your last ten hires you’d make again, knowing what you know now. Here’s the same question with the evidence attached: for each of them, can you point to the one thing in the process that would have told you the answer in advance? If what comes back is mostly a conversation that went well, you don’t have a hiring process. You have a run of luck you’ve been grading as judgement.

See the framework →
Day 018 · Talent Management

The Bar Raiser

How do you stop hiring decisions from drifting toward whoever the team liked most in the room?

See the framework →
Day 182 · Talent Management

The Cost of a Mis-Hire

You already know which hire this is about — the one you should never have made: can you tell me, to the nearest ten thousand, what that person cost you once you’ve counted the severance, your own lost year, the work their colleagues quietly redid, and the customers who left when they did?

See the framework →