Day 209 of the Daily · Marketing

The Consideration Set

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Most of the argument you’ve built will never be read. It’s aimed at people who never put you on the list.

The question

Think about the last five buyers in your category who chose someone else: could you name the three or four options that were genuinely on their list the day they sat down to decide? Most sellers can name exactly one — themselves. The other names on that list are where the decision was actually made.

The idea

John Howard, a professor at Columbia Business School, and his collaborator Jagdish Sheth built one of the first serious models of how a buyer really decides, in The Theory of Buyer Behavior (1969). One piece of it has outlived the rest: what they called the evoked set — the small handful of brands a buyer retrieves and genuinely weighs, out of everything on offer. Choice happens in sequence, not in a single pass. A set gets assembled first, mostly from memory, in seconds, and only then does any comparing begin — and while a few names do get added once that comparing starts, the ones arriving late arrive from sources you don’t own. Two decades later Prakash Nedungadi, at the University of Toronto, ran the experiment that shows how much rides on that first stage: writing in the Journal of Consumer Research in 1990, he demonstrated that making a brand easier to bring to mind raised how often people chose it, without changing what they thought of it at all. Same opinions, different winner. Almost all commercial effort — the case studies, the feature grid, the demo, the proposal, the pricing page — is built for the comparing, and it only ever fires for names that already cleared retrieval.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Consideration Set is Day 209 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Marketing

The next four in the course.

All 28 Marketing frameworks
Day 216 · Marketing

The Funnel and the Journey

Open the diagram your team uses to describe how buyers reach you: is that drawing there to count what happened last quarter, or to decide where the work goes next quarter — and could anyone in the room tell you which? I’ll answer for most teams. It was built to count, it’s being used to plan, and the middle of the picture is where the money quietly stopped going.

See the framework →
Day 222 · Marketing

The Trade-Off Test

Think of the last three things you added because customers said they wanted them — what did each of those customers actually give up to get it? If the answer is nothing, not money, not a feature they’d have to lose, not a longer wait, then you collected a wish list and built a roadmap out of it.

See the framework →
Day 230 · Marketing

The Adoption Curve

Of the customers who’ve bought from you so far, how many would have bought whatever you did, and how many bought because they watched somebody else buy first? Most people can’t split that list, which is why the second year of a launch is where the forecast usually breaks.

See the framework →
Day 238 · Marketing

The Beachhead

Name the one segment where you’d win nearly every deal if everybody in it had simply heard of you — not the biggest market you sell into, the narrowest one you could take completely inside a year. If that name doesn’t arrive in a single sentence, you’ll spend this year as the second-best option in four different markets, and not one of them will hand you a reference the next one recognises.

See the framework →