Day 222 of the Daily · Marketing

The Trade-Off Test

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Ask a customer what matters to them and every answer comes back yes. Today you make them pay for one.

The question

Think of the last three things you added because customers said they wanted them — what did each of those customers actually give up to get it? If the answer is nothing, not money, not a feature they’d have to lose, not a longer wait, then you collected a wish list and built a roadmap out of it.

The idea

Day 133 already put whole packages in front of someone and read the choice back: three proposals worth the same to you, and whichever one they reach for tells you what they value. This morning takes that move and adds the arithmetic that turns a read into a number. Paul Green was a marketing professor at Wharton, and in 1971 he published a paper in the Journal of Marketing Research with Vithala Rao called ‘Conjoint Measurement for Quantifying Judgmental Data’. It took a result from mathematical psychology — R. Duncan Luce and John Tukey had shown in 1964 that the separate contributions of several variables can be recovered from a person’s ordering of the outcomes alone — and pointed it at a problem every operator meets. Ask a buyer how important price, speed, support and reliability are and they’ll rate all four highly, because agreeing costs nothing. Green and Rao stopped asking about attributes. They showed people whole options instead, complete bundles each carrying its own price, and asked them to rank the bundles. What makes that a measurement rather than a read is the design underneath it: the bundles are built to a pattern, so every attribute sits at each of its levels in exactly half of them, which means the other attributes cancel out when you read one. Three offers tell you which package they reached for. A patterned eight tells you how much of that result each attribute was separately carrying. The method reached commercial use quickly: the Courtyard by Marriott concept was designed this way, in a study by Jerry Wind, Green and two colleagues, published in Interfaces in 1989. The trap is treating a stated preference as a measured one. The second trap is sketching the bundles rather than patterning them, which quietly turns the measurement back into a read.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Trade-Off Test is Day 222 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Marketing

The next four in the course.

All 28 Marketing frameworks
Day 230 · Marketing

The Adoption Curve

Of the customers who’ve bought from you so far, how many would have bought whatever you did, and how many bought because they watched somebody else buy first? Most people can’t split that list, which is why the second year of a launch is where the forecast usually breaks.

See the framework →
Day 238 · Marketing

The Beachhead

Name the one segment where you’d win nearly every deal if everybody in it had simply heard of you — not the biggest market you sell into, the narrowest one you could take completely inside a year. If that name doesn’t arrive in a single sentence, you’ll spend this year as the second-best option in four different markets, and not one of them will hand you a reference the next one recognises.

See the framework →
Day 247 · Marketing

The Parity Test

You’ve already picked the comparison you want to be judged against and the one difference that beats it, so work the question underneath: what does a buyer have to stop worrying about before that difference gets a hearing, and which of those worries is a stranger still carrying when they close your deck? Nobody inside your building can answer the second half. That’s why it stays unanswered for years.

See the framework →
Day 254 · Marketing

The Attention Threshold

Take the cheapest line on your media plan — the one whose cost per thousand made the whole schedule affordable — and tell me how many seconds of a real person’s eyes each of those thousand impressions actually bought: not how many were served, not how many cleared a viewability threshold, how many were looked at. Almost nobody holds that number. It’s the one that decides whether the line was cheap or merely low-priced.

See the framework →