Day 116 of the Daily · Financial Management

Cost to Serve

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Somewhere on your customer list is an account everybody is proud of. It costs more to keep than it brings in.

The question

Pick the customer you’d fight hardest to keep: could you say, within a few thousand dollars, what it costs to serve them once the calls, the returns, the bespoke reporting and the chasing of a payment that always lands late are counted? Almost nobody runs that number, and the obstacle is rarely the arithmetic — it’s that the account in question has the most impressive name on the list.

The idea

In September 1988 Harvard Business Review published ‘Measure Costs Right: Make the Right Decisions’, by Robin Cooper and Robert Kaplan, both then at Harvard Business School. It arrived a year after Kaplan and H. Thomas Johnson had argued in Relevance Lost that management accounting had stopped telling managers anything they could act on, and it offered the repair. Stop spreading shared costs across products using a single volume-based measure — direct labour hours, machine hours, revenue — and instead find the activity that actually causes each pool of cost, then charge it out on that. The consequence is uncomfortable and remarkably consistent. Volume-based allocation over-costs the simple, high-volume work and under-costs the small, complicated, customised work, which means your standard product has been quietly subsidising your special ones for years. The method became known as activity-based costing. Its most useful application turned out not to be product costing at all, but pointing the same lens at customers — and finding that profit isn’t distributed anything like revenue is.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Cost to Serve is Day 116 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Financial Management

The next four in the course.

All 28 Financial Management frameworks
Day 120 · Financial Management

The DuPont Decomposition

Your business earns some return on the money its owners have tied up inside it. Could you say this morning whether that return comes from what you charge, from how hard your assets work, or from how much of the place is funded by somebody else? Two of those you built. One of them you borrowed.

See the framework →
Day 123 · Financial Management

Price, Volume, Mix

Take last month’s revenue movement — the number you reported, the number somebody was congratulated for — and say whether it came from charging more, from selling more, or from selling a different blend. If you’re guessing, guess mix: it’s the one that moves your average while every actual price stays exactly where it was.

See the framework →
Day 127 · Financial Management

CAC Payback

Count the months between the day you pay to win a customer and the day that customer has handed the money back, then check which costs you counted and which margin you used. If that number isn’t on a page you look at, the speed you’re allowed to grow is currently being set by whoever last approved a marketing budget.

See the framework →
Day 131 · Financial Management

The LTV Trap

Somewhere in your business is a lifetime value figure that has already been used to justify a decision — a channel, a discount, a hire — and if you can’t say this morning which churn assumption it rests on, what discount rate was applied to it and which cohort it came from, you aren’t measuring what a customer is worth; you’re quoting a number whose provenance you’ve decided not to examine.

See the framework →