Day 131 of the Daily · Financial Management

The LTV Trap

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. The number that justifies your marketing budget was built by the people who spend it.

The question

Somewhere in your business is a lifetime value figure that has already been used to justify a decision — a channel, a discount, a hire — and if you can’t say this morning which churn assumption it rests on, what discount rate was applied to it and which cohort it came from, you aren’t measuring what a customer is worth; you’re quoting a number whose provenance you’ve decided not to examine.

The idea

Bill Gurley, a general partner at the venture firm Benchmark, published ‘The Dangerous Seduction of the Lifetime Value (LTV) Formula’ on his blog Above the Crowd in September 2012. He wasn’t attacking the formula. Lifetime value — the net present value of the profit stream of a customer — he called a good tactical tool for comparing like-minded marketing programmes. What he objected to was what happens when a tool becomes a religion: it relaxes the need for near-term profitability, and it’s usually owned by the very team arguing for the larger budget. His sharpest point is that the inputs aren’t independent. Raise price and churn rises. Spend harder and acquisition cost rises, and the quality of what you buy falls with it. Improve service to hold churn down and cost to serve climbs. Yet many decks show all of them improving together, year after year. The trap is not a wrong number. It is a forecast, built by the people it funds, presented as a fact.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The LTV Trap is Day 131 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Financial Management

The next four in the course.

All 28 Financial Management frameworks
Day 134 · Financial Management

The Price Waterfall

Pick the last invoice you sent and follow it all the way down — past the volume discount, the terms you granted, the freight you absorbed, the credit you issued to end an argument. If the figure at the bottom sits several points below the price you believe you charge, that gap has been running on every deal for years while you’ve been managing the number at the top.

See the framework →
Day 138 · Financial Management

The Elasticity Test

If you raised your price ten per cent tomorrow and lost one customer in ten, would you finish the quarter better off or worse off? On any contribution margin below ninety per cent you’d be better off — and if that answer surprises you, the price has been held where it is by fear and given a strategic name.

See the framework →
Day 142 · Financial Management

Return on Invested Capital

Add up every dollar this business is sitting on this morning — the stock, the unpaid invoices, the fit-out, the equipment, the profit you left in rather than took out — and tell me what percentage of that total came back last year as operating profit. If that percentage is lower than what the same money would have cost you to borrow, what exactly was last year’s growth for?

See the framework →
Day 146 · Financial Management

The Sustainable Growth Rate

If revenue doubled next year while your margin, your payment terms and your stock levels all stayed exactly where they are, how much extra cash would that growth swallow before any of it came back to you? That isn’t a matter of opinion — the speed this business can fund is already written in four numbers you filed last year.

See the framework →