Day 111 of the Daily · Negotiation

Goals Beat Bottom Lines

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. You know the number you’d refuse. Now say the number you intend to get.

The question

What are you actually going for in the negotiation you have coming — a figure you could defend, in a sentence, to a stranger who owes you nothing? What usually arrives instead is a range, a feeling, or the phrase ‘as much as I can get’. The distance between that and a defended number is what the other side collects, and they don’t have to be skilful to do it.

The idea

G. Richard Shell teaches negotiation at Wharton, where he is professor of legal studies, business ethics and management and academic director of the Executive Negotiation Workshop. Bargaining for Advantage (1999) opens where most preparation stops: at the difference between a bottom line and a goal. Your bottom line is the point below which no deal beats your alternative. It’s defensive, it’s derived, and its single function is to tell you when to stand up. Your goal is what you’re trying to achieve, and Shell’s case is that the goal, not the floor, is what moves the result. He draws on Sidney Siegel and Lawrence Fouraker’s bargaining experiments of 1960, which found that what a negotiator ends up with tracks the level they aspired to. Shell’s standard for setting one is a number that is optimistic and justifiable at the same time. The trouble is that a floor is easy to write and a target is exposing. So the floor gets written, and the meeting is spent negotiating towards it.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Goals Beat Bottom Lines is Day 111 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Negotiation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Negotiation frameworks
Day 115 · Negotiation

The Fairness Standard

Take the negotiation where you and the other side are furthest apart. Can you state the rule producing their number — market rate, cost plus a margin, precedent, what the last supplier charged, what the outcome is worth to them — in a form they’d recognise as a fair account of their own thinking? An argument about a figure is usually an argument between two rules nobody has named, and until one of them gets named the dispute can run for weeks with neither side ever having to change its mind.

See the framework →
Day 118 · Negotiation

Inside Their Head

Write down, in their language rather than yours, the case the other side will put on the table — what they need, what they’re frightened of, what their own boss would punish them for conceding — and if you can’t fill half a page, why haven’t you prepared the half of the room you do not already know by heart?

See the framework →
Day 122 · Negotiation

The Calibrated Question

Somewhere in your current deal is a line you’ve now sent three times in a slightly firmer voice; hand them the constraint instead and ask how they’d work inside it. What comes back is the thing you’ve been guessing at for a fortnight — so what is the fourth repetition for?

See the framework →
Day 126 · Negotiation

The Fixed-Pie Illusion

Name the issue in your current negotiation that you and the other side would both settle the same way this morning. If nothing comes inside a minute, what have three weeks of defending a number actually bought you?

See the framework →