Day 126 of the Daily · Negotiation

The Fixed-Pie Illusion

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Somewhere in the deal you’re working on sits an issue you both want settled the same way. Neither of you has mentioned it.

The question

Name the issue in your current negotiation that you and the other side would both settle the same way this morning. If nothing comes inside a minute, what have three weeks of defending a number actually bought you?

The idea

In 1990 Leigh Thompson, who now teaches dispute resolution at Northwestern’s Kellogg School, and Reid Hastie, a psychologist of judgement, published ‘Social Perception in Negotiation’ in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. They ran negotiators through tasks built from a mixture of issues: some genuinely opposed, some where the two sides differed in how much they cared, and some where both parties wanted the identical outcome. Then they measured what people believed about the other side. Negotiator after negotiator arrived assuming the interests were directly opposed on everything — the fixed-pie perception — and most of what they learned otherwise, they learned in the first few minutes. A second, distinct error is the incompatibility error: you miss the issues on which you already agree, and hand over for free something the other side would happily have granted. Those who learned the other side’s interests early did better than those who learned them late. The illusion isn’t pessimism about the other side. It’s a failure to ask.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Fixed-Pie Illusion is Day 126 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Negotiation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Negotiation frameworks
Day 129 · Negotiation

The Exchange Rate

Take the deal closest to closing and rank its issues twice, once by what conceding each would cost you and once by what winning each is probably worth to them. Can you point to the row that’s cheap on your list and expensive on theirs? If the two rankings come out looking the same, you have ranked one side of the table twice, and every swap you price this week will be priced off that single sketch.

See the framework →
Day 133 · Negotiation

Three Offers at Once

Think about the last proposal you sent and the reply that came back. Beyond yes, no, or a lower number, what did it teach you about which parts of the deal your counterparty actually cared about? If nothing comes to mind, that’s the price of giving them one thing to react to: building three is work, and sending one feels like progress right up until the reply arrives.

See the framework →
Day 136 · Negotiation

The Contingent Agreement

Take the deal you’re most stuck on this week and work out what the distance is actually made of: are you apart on what the thing is worth today, or on two sincere and incompatible forecasts of what happens after signing — and if it’s the second, what exactly is the money you concede before Friday buying?

See the framework →
Day 140 · Negotiation

Create Before You Claim

In your last real negotiation, was there something true you didn’t say — a constraint, a priority, a trade you’d happily have accepted — because you couldn’t see how to say it without handing over leverage? You walked out with the smaller deal. Somewhere between then and now, that silence got promoted from caution to strategy.

See the framework →