Day 109 of the Daily · Financial Management

The Quality of Earnings

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. Somebody chose your profit, inside the rules. Today you find out which choices they made.

The question

Of the profit your last accounts reported, how much arrived as money in the bank and how much arrived as a judgement somebody made about timing? Both lines are already sitting in accounts you’ve filed. Leave them on separate pages and you’re steering by a figure that was partly chosen for you.

The idea

Howard Schilit published Financial Shenanigans in 1993, a field guide to the ways a reported profit gets manufactured, and founded the forensic research firm CFRA the following year. His catalogue went through them one at a time — revenue recorded too soon, revenue that was never real, revenue held back from a strong period to lift a weaker one, expenses shifted into a later period, expenses dragged into the current one, liabilities left unrecorded, one-off gains dressed up as trading income — and every one of them moves the profit line without moving a dollar. That’s the part most operators miss. Accounting is a set of choices made inside rules: when revenue is recognised, whether a cost becomes an asset or an expense, how long a machine is assumed to last, how much of a provision counts as prudent. Two businesses with identical bank accounts can lawfully report materially different profits, and neither of them has broken anything. The simplest check is the one Schilit calls the conventional wisdom: track reported profit against cash generated from operations across several periods, because the gap between them is where the choices accumulate, though he warns that operating cash flow can be massaged too.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Quality of Earnings is Day 109 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Financial Management

The next four in the course.

All 28 Financial Management frameworks
Day 113 · Financial Management

Operating Leverage

If revenue fell fifteen per cent next quarter through nothing you did wrong — a slow market, one client pausing, a season that never arrived — would profit fall fifteen per cent, forty, or straight through zero? Two subtractions and a division, off your own P&L, answer that in about four minutes. Every month you haven’t run them is a month you’ve carried a risk you can’t size.

See the framework →
Day 116 · Financial Management

Cost to Serve

Pick the customer you’d fight hardest to keep: could you say, within a few thousand dollars, what it costs to serve them once the calls, the returns, the bespoke reporting and the chasing of a payment that always lands late are counted? Almost nobody runs that number, and the obstacle is rarely the arithmetic — it’s that the account in question has the most impressive name on the list.

See the framework →
Day 120 · Financial Management

The DuPont Decomposition

Your business earns some return on the money its owners have tied up inside it. Could you say this morning whether that return comes from what you charge, from how hard your assets work, or from how much of the place is funded by somebody else? Two of those you built. One of them you borrowed.

See the framework →
Day 123 · Financial Management

Price, Volume, Mix

Take last month’s revenue movement — the number you reported, the number somebody was congratulated for — and say whether it came from charging more, from selling more, or from selling a different blend. If you’re guessing, guess mix: it’s the one that moves your average while every actual price stays exactly where it was.

See the framework →