Day 098 of the Daily · Leadership

The Authority Illusion

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. They’ll all turn up on Monday. Only some of them will do more than turn up.

The question

Open last week’s calendar and total the hours you spent doing work that belongs to somebody who reports to you — the deck you rebuilt at eleven at night, the client call you took because you handle that client better — and if you can name the biggest one right now, why haven’t you handed it back?

The idea

Linda A. Hill, the Wallace Brett Donham Professor of Business Administration at Harvard Business School, followed nineteen people through their first year as managers and published what she found in Becoming a Manager: Mastery of a New Identity (Harvard Business School Press, 1992). Almost all of them started from the same assumption: the promotion had handed them authority, and authority would do the work. It didn’t. What they learned, usually painfully and usually well into the year, is that formal position buys attendance, compliance and the minimum, while everything above the minimum has to be earned person by person — through demonstrated competence, through character that holds on a bad week, and through an ability to get things done for the team rather than to it. Under that pressure new managers do the reasonable thing and retreat into the technical work they were already good at, because that is where the old competence still lives. The trap is that the retreat looks like diligence. The hours are real, the output is excellent, and every one of them is an hour your team spent unled.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Authority Illusion is Day 98 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Leadership

The next four in the course.

All 26 Leadership frameworks
Day 102 · Leadership

The Trust Equation

Pick the person you manage whose trust in you has thinned, and answer the half you’d rather not: is it that you got a call wrong and never fixed it, or that they’ve worked out what these conversations do for you and have been managing your reaction ever since?

See the framework →
Day 106 · Leadership

The Readiness Match

Take the three pieces of work you handed out on Monday and say, for each one, whether that person can actually do this particular thing and whether they actually want to. Now say where your grip came from. It wasn’t those two answers, was it — it was an impression of them you formed last year and have never revisited.

See the framework →
Day 110 · Leadership

The Motivation Chain

Think of the person who has stopped pushing — still present, still polite, still delivering exactly what was asked and nothing past it. Three beliefs sit under any effort past the minimum: that it produces the result, that the result produces the reward, and that the reward is worth having. One of the three has gone. They know which one, and you have never asked.

See the framework →
Day 114 · Leadership

Can’t, or Won’t

Put Mager’s question to yourself about the person whose performance you have given up on: if their life depended on doing this work properly tomorrow, could they do it? If the honest answer is yes, then every hour of coaching you have spent went into a gap that was never there. What needs examining is what happens around here to somebody who gets this right.

See the framework →