Day 084 of the Daily · Decision Making

Bayesian Updating

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. You are allowed to be forty per cent sure. Almost nobody takes the option.

The question

Name a belief you have carried about your business for a year — a conversion rate, a renewal assumption, a channel’s payback — and say what has arrived since that should have moved it a few points either way. If nothing has moved it, the reason is rarely that the evidence went quiet; it is that the belief never had a number on it, and a belief without a number has nothing to move.

The idea

Thomas Bayes was an English Presbyterian minister and amateur mathematician who died in 1761 leaving an unpublished essay behind him. His friend Richard Price edited it and sent it to the Royal Society, where it was read in 1763 as An Essay towards Solving a Problem in the Doctrine of Chances, and it became the standard grammar of evidence: a belief is a probability rather than a verdict, and evidence should revise it in proportion to how much better it fits one answer than the other. You hold a prior, evidence arrives, you land on a posterior — which is simply the prior for whatever comes next. Philip Tetlock, professor at the University of Pennsylvania, found the working version in the forecasting tournaments he and Dan Gardner describe in Superforecasting (2015): the most accurate forecasters were not the boldest, but the ones who updated often, in small increments, on ordinary evidence. Most operators do the opposite. They hold a position at full strength until something forces a reversal, then reverse completely, and call both halves judgement.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Bayesian Updating is Day 84 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Decision Making

The next four in the course.

All 28 Decision Making frameworks
Day 086 · Decision Making

The Two-Way Mirror

Think about the decision you are about to hand to somebody else — the restructure, the offer, the terms you are about to tighten, the memo you have already drafted: could you write their objection in their own words, sharply enough that they would nod at it; and if you have only ever rehearsed your own side, what are you quietly hoping the meeting will do that your preparation refused to?

See the framework →
Day 088 · Decision Making

Scenario Trees

Take the decision sitting heaviest on you this week: could you write down this morning what you would decide next under each way the world might answer it? Almost nobody can, which is why the second decision — the one that usually sets the outcome — ends up being made in a hurry by whoever happens to be in the room.

See the framework →
Day 090 · Decision Making

The Cost of Delay

Name the decision you have formally put back — the hire moved to next quarter, the price rise held for the new financial year, the supplier review rescheduled twice — and tell me to the nearest thousand what each week of that wait has cost you. If no number comes, the wait was never free; it is only that nobody sends you the bill.

See the framework →
Day 092 · Decision Making

Committing Publicly

Which decision have you already made and never said out loud to anyone who could hold you to it — the resignation letter drafted and not sent, the pricing note sitting in your drafts folder, the restructure your partner has heard in full and nobody at work has heard at all? Name the person who would have to hear it for it to become real, and then notice how quickly you found a reason not to tell them.

See the framework →