Day 332 of the Daily · Brand Management

Brand Dilution

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

An extension is a wire, not a pipe — current runs in both directions.

The question

Think about the last thing your company launched under the main brand name: if you asked twenty long-standing customers today what your name stands for, would the answer come back narrower or broader than it was three years ago — and could you name which launch moved it? Broader sounds like progress. In memory it means fewer people can finish the sentence.

The idea

Yesterday’s three conditions gated the new product, and the architecture choice behind them set where equity is meant to flow; both look forward, at the thing being launched. Barbara Loken and Deborah Roedder John, both marketing professors at the University of Minnesota, asked the question that research had mostly skipped: never mind the new product, what happens to the parent? Their 1993 paper in the Journal of Marketing, Diluting Brand Beliefs: When Do Brand Extensions Have a Negative Impact?, found that beliefs about a family brand shift when an extension contradicts them — customers rate the parent measurably lower on the belief in question. The counterintuitive part is where the damage lands. An extension far from the parent does less harm, because customers file it as a special case that says nothing about the brand; the mind builds a subtype and protects the original. The extension sitting close in, typical enough to read as representative, is the one that rewrites the definition. Dilution sits in what customers believe rather than in the accounts, so no sales report will ever raise it. John, Loken and Christopher Joiner returned to the question in 1998 and found the flagship product itself holds up rather well. It’s the family name, the thing carrying everything else, that gives ground first.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Brand Dilution is Day 332 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Brand Management

The next four in the course.

All 22 Brand Management frameworks
Day 341 · Brand Management

The Goodwill Reservoir

When your business next does something genuinely wrong — the order lost, the outage, the invoice that was quietly incorrect for a year — will your customers read it as unlike you, or as finally what they’d suspected all along? You already know which one it’ll be. You’ve been answering that question for years, in every small thing you did when nobody was watching.

See the framework →
Day 350 · Brand Management

Brand Valuation

If someone offered to buy the business this quarter on the condition that the name stayed behind — same products, same people, same customers, a different badge on all of it — how much would you take off the price, and could you defend that figure for longer than a sentence? Most owners have never put a number on the difference. It’s the largest thing they’ve built and the only asset they’ve never priced.

See the framework →
Day 359 · Brand Management

The Brand Operating Review

When somebody asks you six months from now whether the brand is stronger than it was, what will you actually reach for — the refresh you shipped, one good quarter of sales, the feeling in the room? You’ll reach for whichever number is nearest. It’ll be a sales number wearing brand clothes, and it won’t tell you a thing about the asset you spent the year paying for.

See the framework →
Day 019 · Brand Management

Brand Architecture

When you add a new product line, does it strengthen your brand or quietly dilute it?

See the framework →