Day 301 of the Daily · Marketing

The Mix Test

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Your product team, your pricing, your channel and your advertising are each describing a brand. They’re not describing the same one.

The question

If you wrote down in one sentence each what your product is for, what your price signals, where a buyer can actually get it, and what your advertising says — then read the four back in a row — would a stranger believe they were describing the same company? Most teams find the contradiction inside a minute. Their buyers found it years ago.

The idea

The marketing mix began life as a metaphor about cooking. James Culliton, studying what marketing actually cost American manufacturers, described the executive who ran it as a mixer of ingredients, and Neil Borden, who taught advertising at Harvard Business School, built a whole way of thinking on the image. He had been using the term since the late 1940s and put it to the American Marketing Association in his presidential address of 1953, though he only wrote it up for the field in the Journal of Advertising Research in 1964. His list ran to twelve elements — product planning, pricing, branding, channels of distribution, personal selling, advertising, promotions, packaging, display, servicing, physical handling, and fact-finding. Thorough, and unusable in a meeting. The version that stuck came from E. Jerome McCarthy, whose Basic Marketing: A Managerial Approach compressed Borden’s ingredients into four in 1960: product, price, place, promotion. Sixty-odd years of business schools later the four Ps get taught as a checklist, which is the least interesting thing they do. Their real use is as a consistency test. Each P is a statement about who you’re for and what you’re worth, made by a different part of the company, usually on a different day, and almost never read alongside the other three. A premium product sold through a discount channel isn’t two decisions. It’s one contradiction, and your buyer resolves it in whichever direction costs you money.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Mix Test is Day 301 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Marketing

The next four in the course.

All 28 Marketing frameworks
Day 309 · Marketing

Route to Market

Of all the jobs that sit between your product being finished and a customer having it in hand — holding the stock, explaining it, taking the order, carrying the credit, chasing the payment, handling returns, carrying the risk that none of it sells — which ones does somebody else currently do for you, and what precisely are you paying them for? If you have never listed them out, here’s the likely answer: you’re doing most of them yourself and charging nobody, while paying a partner a margin for two and assuming they cover five.

See the framework →
Day 317 · Marketing

Excess Share of Voice

Add up what everyone chasing your buyer spent last year on being seen, work out your slice of it, and set that slice beside your share of the sales — which of the two is larger? If it’s the sales, you’re not being efficient. You’re funding your own decline in instalments.

See the framework →
Day 323 · Marketing

The Advertising Half-Life

Think about the last time you went quiet — the campaign that ended, the month the budget got frozen, the quarter you spent rebuilding the website instead — and tell me how long it took before the effect had actually run out. You can’t. Almost nobody can, and it’s the number that decides whether a pause is a saving or a slow write-off.

See the framework →
Day 330 · Marketing

Recency Planning

Look at the schedule you’re running now — the launch month, the burst, the fortnight when everything goes out at once — and ask yourself how many of your category’s buyers were anywhere near a decision during those weeks, and what the other forty, when they heard nothing at all from you, actually cost.

See the framework →