Day 265 of the Daily · Brand Management

Identity Myths

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Most brands sell a product. A few of them settle an argument the culture hasn’t been able to settle for itself.

The question

When your customers argue with themselves about who they’re supposed to be — at work, at home, in the country they live in — does your brand have a single thing to say to that argument, or does it only ever have things to say about itself? A brand that can only talk about itself competes on features and price forever, because that is the only ground it has left.

The idea

Douglas Holt taught marketing at Harvard Business School and went on to hold a marketing chair at Oxford’s Saïd Business School. His 2004 book, How Brands Become Icons, is an argument with almost everything else on this reading list. The conventional model — Holt calls it mind-share branding — says you win by owning a few consistent associations in enough heads. His objection is that it can’t explain the brands people actually revere. Coke, Budweiser, Nike, Volkswagen and Mountain Dew didn’t become icons by being better remembered. They became icons by performing what Holt calls an identity myth: a story that resolved a contradiction the country was living inside, between what people were told they ought to be and what their lives actually allowed. Nike’s Just Do It arrived in 1988 and worked because it took the will to overcome from a world America found credible — the playground, the athlete with nothing — and handed it to people whose own lives had stalled. The trap is that myths expire. A contradiction belongs to a moment, so the brands that stayed iconic rewrote the story once the moment passed, which is exactly the inconsistency the conventional model warns you against. Most brands never face that problem, for the simple reason that they aren’t saying anything about the world at all.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Identity Myths is Day 265 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Brand Management

The next four in the course.

All 22 Brand Management frameworks
Day 275 · Brand Management

Brand Community

You have an audience if your customers all face you, and a community if they face each other. So: if two of your customers were seated next to each other at a dinner with no idea they had you in common, how long would it take them to find out — and would either of them care enough to mention it?

See the framework →
Day 284 · Brand Management

The Sound of the Name

If you handed your brand name to a stranger who knew nothing about you and asked whether it sounds fast or slow, big or small, hard or soft, would their answer match what you actually sell — or is your marketing quietly paying, on every new customer for the life of the business, to overwrite an impression the name made first?

See the framework →
Day 294 · Brand Management

The Standards Manual

Pull up the last three things your business put in front of a customer — a deck, an invoice, a social post — and hold them beside each other: is it the same blue, the same mark at the same weight, the same two typefaces, and did somebody have to make a judgement call to produce any of them? Every judgement call you leave available is a small withdrawal from the same account.

See the framework →
Day 303 · Brand Management

The Price Premium

Name the one thing your buyers would genuinely buy instead of you, then work out how far its price would have to fall before they’d walk away from yours — and of that difference, how much survives the standing discount, the quarterly promotion and the deal your best rep closed last Friday? Most operators can guess the first number. Almost nobody has calculated the second, and the second is the only one that ever reached the bank.

See the framework →