Day 235 of the Daily · Innovation

Dominant Design

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Every category eventually stops arguing about what the product should be. The day it stops isn’t marked.

The question

Look at the last five deals you lost and ask what the winner was actually offering: a different idea of what this product should be, or the same idea built cheaper, faster and more reliably than yours? One of those answers means the category’s still open. The other means the argument closed while you were still preparing your side of it.

The idea

In 1975 James Utterback and William Abernathy — Utterback at MIT, Abernathy at Harvard Business School — published a dynamic model of process and product innovation in the journal Omega, and took it further in Technology Review in 1978. Their claim was that categories move through phases. Early on, in the fluid phase, nobody’s agreed what the product even is: rival architectures, rival materials, rival ideas of who the customer is, and product innovation running hot. Then one configuration wins enough of the market to become the reference every entrant is judged against — the dominant design — and the basis of competition swings to process, volume and cost. Philip Anderson and Michael Tushman extended the model in Administrative Science Quarterly in 1990, studying the American cement, glass and minicomputer industries, and added the uncomfortable part: the design that wins is rarely the most advanced one on the bench. It doesn’t win on the bench at all. It wins through licensing, distribution, regulation, supplier commitments and plain timing. Which means you can hold the technically better product and still find you’re competing on a standard someone else set, in a game that now rewards manufacturing discipline rather than the invention you were built for.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

Dominant Design is Day 235 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Innovation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Innovation frameworks
Day 240 · Innovation

Architectural Innovation

When something new turns up in your market and you hand it to the person who knows your product best, what comes back? I can guess: they’ll tell you it’s the same components you already use, assembled a little differently, with nothing in it you could not build yourselves inside a quarter — and every word of that will be true.

See the framework →
Day 249 · Innovation

Get Out of the Building

Take the single biggest assumption your plan rests on — who the buyer really is, what they’d pay, why they’d leave what they use now — and ask yourself honestly where the evidence for it came from: a conversation this month with someone who owes you nothing, or a room full of people who already agree with you?

See the framework →
Day 258 · Innovation

Absorptive Capacity

Think of the last outside thing your business decided against — the technology, the method, the research somebody forwarded up the chain, the partner’s proposal — and ask honestly whether you turned it down because you’d understood it and judged it wrong for you, or because nobody in the room held enough of the underlying subject to tell the difference. Both verdicts get minuted the same way, and only one of them is a decision.

See the framework →
Day 267 · Innovation

The Double Diamond

The last project your team ran — the one with a deadline and a budget attached — how much of it went on deciding what the problem actually was, before anyone started drawing the answer? For most teams that’s a single meeting, and it’s called the kick-off.

See the framework →