Day 211 of the Daily · Talent Management

The External Premium

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. The role opened and you looked outside. Someone in the building was closer than you think.

The question

The last role you filled from outside — the one where you were certain you needed fresh thinking — did you need someone you couldn’t have grown, or someone you simply hadn’t started growing eighteen months earlier? You paid nearly a fifth extra for the difference, and then waited two years for the work.

The idea

Matthew Bidwell of the Wharton School got hold of years of personnel records from the US investment-banking arm of a large financial firm and asked something survey data can’t answer: what actually happens to the people you hire in, compared with the people you move across? The paper ran in Administrative Science Quarterly in 2011 under the title Paying More to Get Less, which saves you reading it. External hires were initially paid around eighteen per cent more than workers promoted into similar jobs. They arrived with more education and more experience on paper. And for their first two years they were rated as worse performers, and they left at higher rates. The ones still standing caught up after about two years, and moved up faster than the people who had been promoted into the job. The reason isn’t mysterious. An internal mover already holds everything an interview can’t test: who to ask, how decisions really get made, what the last attempt at this cost and why it failed. You bought a CV and paid a premium to swap three years of context for none. The trap is treating fresh thinking as a property of the role rather than an alibi for never having grown anyone into it.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The External Premium is Day 211 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Talent Management

The next four in the course.

All 19 Talent Management frameworks
Day 221 · Talent Management

The Weak-Tie Search

If you had to fill a hard role by the end of the month, whose names would you ring first — and how many of those people sit in the meetings you sit in, read what you read, and would hand you back the same three candidates you’ve already met twice? Your closest contacts aren’t a network. They’re a mirror.

See the framework →
Day 231 · Talent Management

The Honest Preview

Write down the three worst true things about working in the role you’re hiring for — the ones a good candidate only discovers in week six. Now: would you put them in the advert, or does that feel like handing a competitor a gift?

See the framework →
Day 244 · Talent Management

The Predictor Ranking

Add up the hours your last hire’s process actually consumed — the CV sift, the coffee, the panel conversation about whether they’d fit — and then add up the hours that produced a written score against a stated outcome: which number is larger, and what does that ratio say about what you truly believe predicts performance?

See the framework →
Day 253 · Talent Management

The Blind Screen

Take the last twenty applications you turned down and ask what actually did the turning down: was it evidence weighed against the outcomes you wrote for the role, or was it the university, the unexplained gap in the dates, the company you’d never heard of, the name you couldn’t place? One of those you could defend to the candidate a year later. Which one were you reading?

See the framework →