Day 158 of the Daily · Negotiation

The Negotiauction

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Morning. You’ve been calling this a negotiation. It’s a process, and somebody else is writing the rules.

The question

Look at the deal you most want to close this quarter and count the credible parties genuinely in the field. If the count is one, you probably didn’t conclude there was nobody else worth approaching; you just never made the calls, and from the inside those two feel identical. Who gets the first one?

The idea

Guhan Subramanian holds tenured chairs at both Harvard Law School and Harvard Business School, and in 2010 he published Negotiauctions, reissued the following year as Dealmaking: The New Strategy of Negotiauctions, to close a gap in the received wisdom on dealmaking. Negotiation gets treated as one subject and auctions as another: negotiation as two parties trading across a table, auctions as many bidders under fixed rules. Real deals, he argued, are almost always hybrids. You bargain with one counterparty while competing against others whose existence and seriousness you can’t fully verify, and while the rules themselves are still being written: who is invited, in what order, against what deadline, with what information. Subramanian’s name for this is the negotiauction, and his point is that the rules are the game. Arrive as a pure negotiator, ready to trade skilfully inside a process somebody else designed, and you’ll find most of the outcome was settled before your first meeting.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Negotiauction is Day 158 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Negotiation

The next four in the course.

All 24 Negotiation frameworks
Day 161 · Negotiation

The Two-Level Game

Picture yourself carrying this week’s deal back into your own building: name the three people who have to live with it, name what each one will object to, and then notice that you’ve been planning to win them over afterwards rather than consult them first. That is a decision to spend your negotiating position on a fight you could have had for free.

See the framework →
Day 165 · Negotiation

The Final Offer

Think of the last time you told a counterparty a number was final and then moved it, and ask what that round actually cost you. The price wasn’t the difference between the two numbers; it was teaching a person you’ll negotiate with again exactly how much your word about a limit is worth.

See the framework →
Day 169 · Negotiation

Signed Is Not Done

Name the last agreement you signed that under-delivered — scope grew, a service level nobody could meet got promised, an integration took three times as long — and then say who from the delivering side was in the room when those terms were agreed, because deal teams promise what delivery teams have to survive, and that bill gets paid every month of the contract by people who never saw the negotiation.

See the framework →
Day 173 · Negotiation

The Negotiation Operating Review

Pull up every negotiation you’re running now and every one you closed this quarter, and try to say, for each, what your alternative was worth, where the zone actually sat and what you gave away to reach yes. The ones you can’t answer won’t be the small ones. They’ll be the ones you ran on nerve and afterwards described as instinct.

See the framework →