Day 149 of the Daily · Financial Management

The Rolling Forecast

5 min read · 4 principles · apply it by lunch

Good morning. The number you’re steering by this week was agreed by people who didn’t know what you know now.

The question

Open the budget you approved for this year and find the revenue line for the quarter you’re currently in. If you can’t say, without asking anybody, whether that figure is a target you’re chasing, a forecast you believe, or a spending permission somebody is still drawing against, then it’s doing all three jobs at once and none of them properly.

The idea

Jeremy Hope and Robin Fraser led the Beyond Budgeting Round Table, formed in 1998 to study organisations that had abandoned the annual budget, and set out the case in Beyond Budgeting: How Managers Can Break Free from the Annual Performance Trap (2003). Their diagnosis is precise. The budget isn’t one instrument but three fused into a single negotiated number: a target saying what you should achieve, a forecast saying what you honestly expect, and a permission saying what you may spend. Fuse them, attach anyone’s pay or standing to the result, and the forecast is corrupted at the moment of writing, because people don’t submit their best estimate when the estimate becomes the bar. Their standing example is Svenska Handelsbanken, whose chief executive Jan Wallander abolished the bank’s budget in 1970 and replaced it with fast actuals and open comparison between branches. Wallander went further than the movement that later adopted him: he called budgeting an unnecessary evil, on the grounds that a forecast either repeats the present or misses the turn that matters, and the bank steered on results and relative standing instead of a figure for next year. That makes Handelsbanken the proof that the annual number can go altogether, and the rolling horizon the answer for everyone who still needs to see a year ahead. The trap is that most companies feel the problem and respond by budgeting harder — more lines, more detail, more re-forecasts, all of it still defending a number agreed before the year began.

In the Daily · 4 principles and a template

The Rolling Forecast is Day 149 of 365.

In the Daily, each of its four principles is explained in full, with a one-page template to apply it the same day. A new framework arrives every morning at 7am for a year, across all fifteen courses of the FutureMBA curriculum.

$29 a month · cancel any time · 7-day money-back guarantee

More from Financial Management

The next four in the course.

All 28 Financial Management frameworks
Day 153 · Financial Management

Zero-Base Budgeting

Find the third-largest line in your operating costs and say who set that number, in what year, and what it beat to get funded — and if the honest answer is that it’s last year’s figure with a little added, then you’ve just described nearly every line beneath it as well, and the questioning of those lines has never once been somebody’s actual job.

See the framework →
Day 156 · Financial Management

The Hurdle Rate

When you last approved a spend of real consequence — the hire, the fit-out, the second location, the new market — what return did it have to clear before it earned the yes, and if you can’t name that number or say what it’s built from, why haven’t you set it, given that every approval you’ve ever signed used one silently anyway?

See the framework →
Day 160 · Financial Management

Net Present Value

Take the commitment you’re weighing this month — the one where the money leaves now and comes back over years. Have you written the cash out year by year and pulled each year back into today’s money, or have you been holding a total against a total and calling the gap a return, which is the comparison that makes every slow payback look clever? Twenty minutes and a column of divisions. The years you haven’t written down are the ones doing the arguing.

See the framework →
Day 164 · Financial Management

The Capital Allocation Slate

Of the money your business generated last year and didn’t need in order to keep operating, how much went straight back into the existing business simply because that is the channel money has always run down? If you have never once set reinvestment, an acquisition, the loan, a distribution and holding cash side by side on one page, the allocation still happened this year, and drift is what made it.

See the framework →